video game style illustration of bugs

Illustration by Joe O’Donnell

A Cultural History of the Ideas that Have Facilitated Antibiotic Resistance

Lorenzo Servitje examines how different media forms have posited the idea of antibiotics.

Story by

Kelly Hochbein

Photography by

Illustrations by Joe O’Donnell

Forget the rise of the machines. The real danger, says Lorenzo Servitje, is the rise of antibiotic-resistant bacteria. Servitje’s latest book project, The Science and Fiction of Antibiosis, is a cultural history of the ideas that have facilitated antibiotic resistance. The book traces the rise of antibiotics through 19th- and early 20th-century medical and scientific prose, and accounts for the science-fictional qualities of the “post-antibiotic apocalypse” in contemporary media coverage and representations of antibiotic resistance.

Antibiotic overuse in medicine, its adoption as a growth-promoting agent in animal agriculture, and lack of regulation in some parts of the world compound the problem, which can result in bacterial infections—perhaps even those common today—that doctors one day will have no means of treating. 

Servitje, an assistant professor of literature and medicine in the department of English, posits that society can misread the problem of antibiotic resistance by thinking of it in the same way that viral emergent diseases such as Ebola and bird flu are represented in the press and popular culture: one bacteria that will wipe us all out. That’s not the case, he says, because bacteria share resistant genes with each other, which means something like E. coli (the common cause of urinary tract infections) or S. pneumoniae (the common cause of sinus infections) could become something much more dangerous than a temporary discomfort for both the single patient and his or her community. 

“Antibiotic resistance is scary and fascinating because it’s a slow-burn problem, much like climate change,” says Servitje. “Certainly that will lead itself to cataclysmic events, but it’s going to start changing the quotidian nature of life, in a very, very slow capacity. That makes it harder to notice and also makes it much, much worse.” 

Scientists have not created a new class of antibiotics since 1987, and drug companies have no incentive to develop newer ones given the more favorable return of investment associated with long-term medications. Moreover, the sources for easily cultured, naturally derived antibiotics have been effectively overmined. Beyond its threat to human health, the rise of resistance, combined with a lack of new antibiotics, creates significant societal and ethical problems, says Servitje. Those without access to quality health care and education often share left-over medications, or take them without a prescription, further strengthening resistance and, with it, class divisions the world over. Doctors must perform a “science-fictional ethical calculus” in deciding how to treat current patients with regard to future patients and the potential for resistant infections.

Servitje’s first book, Medicine Is War: The Martial Metaphor in Victorian Literature and Culture, explores the rise through Victorian literature of society’s militarized understanding of medicine—the so-called “war on disease.” In the book, currently in press, Servitje follows the literary treatment of disease in what he calls “an arc that goes from Romantic literature all the way to modernist.” 

Video game style image of bug in a cage

The “scorched earth” approach to fighting disease and the language associated with it, he says, are reflected again in the post-antibiotic apocalypse, but this time, bacteria are winning the war. 

The Science and Fiction of Antibiosis rises from the afterword of Medicine Is War, in which Servitje writes, “Indeed, if the martial metaphor structured the war on germs from the early 20th century until the end of the golden age of medicine in the 1980s, then apocalypse is the current metaphor in the popular press and scientific publication for articulating the failure of the total war on bacterial infections.”  

The new book will examine a variety of media, including video games, graphic novels and films. It will include Servitje’s publication in Osiris, the journal for the History of Science Society,  “Gaming the Apocalypse in the Time of Antibiotic Resistance,” which examines a mobile video game developed to increase awareness of antibiotic resistance. He describes “how the mobile gaming medium uniquely responds to and performs the science fictionality of the antibiotic apocalypse in a way that has consequences for the history of science.” 

His book, Servitje says, will trace a historical change but also “how this idea [of antibiotics] has been posited in different media forms and why it matters that you understand it, textually or visually or texturally or filmically or ludically through video games.” 

This understanding, he says, might help society respond more responsibly to the growing threat of antibiotic-resistant bacteria.

Story by

Kelly Hochbein

Photography by

Illustrations by Joe O’Donnell

Related Stories

Bird flying over illustrations of people covered in white

American Literature and the Metaphor of Human Waste

Mary Foltz examines the ways several postmodern authors use representations of human excrement to critique how people treat each other and the natural world.

Image of writer Gloria Naylor in profile in front of bookshelf filled with books.

Excerpts from Gloria Naylor’s Unfinished Manuscript 'Sapphira Wade' Published for the First Time

The largely unknown manuscript is a draft of the opening chapter of a prequel to Naylor’s critically acclaimed novel Mama Day.

The title illustration from a 1678 pamphlet called “The Mowing-Devil: Or, Strange News out of Hartford-shire.” A devil-like character pushing a mower through a field.

The Deeper Meaning of Horror

Dawn Keetley’s current projects take a closer look at popular horror film ‘Get Out’ and folk horror in the 21st century.